Not 300, but 30,000, and a new strategy for Afghanistan, based in part on protecting the population centers like Kandahar–Taliban central. What makes me sick about the whole thing is the political theater surrounding the decision. The Right, which clearly wants Obama to fail, is ridiculing the plan as too little too late. Fox’s Hannity implied that the president’s popularity, at a low, is a reflection of this weakness, knowing full well that the real blow to Obama’s political cache, and subsequently his popularity, is coming from his own party and base, many of whom see the escalation of troops to Afghanistan, as MSNBCs Left leaning Oberman put it, campaign promises made now broken.
The fact is, the decision to send 30,000 troops was based on a good deal of thought, rounded out with political expediency for course–but based on considerable instruction and debate amongst our nation’s military leadership. There have been numerous plans put forward from within the military community, many with merit, from which the president had to decide. In the end, president Obama made a decision based on the data and recommendations from the military elite in this country, that in addition to Gen McCristol, included Bush appointed Sec Gates, National Security Advisor Jones, CENTCOM commander Gen Petreaus, and a host of other respected and in-the-know military leaders.
Is it the right decision? Only time will tell. It is a tough one to be sure–for any president to make. However, we ought all to remember that during the campaign Obama one-uped McCain on a nationally televised debate, stating that the US under his leadership would fight on in Afghanistan to success and hunt down and kill bin Laden for the security of the region and the United States. McCain, whom I admire greatly, his only counter, because basically Obama took a traditionally hawkish i.e., Republican stand on Afghanistan, was to confront Obama on making his plan public.
This is one campaign promise President Obama is keeping, and it ought to make the Right happy because this is what it has clamored for–but it wont. And he isn’t going to make any more friends and supporters on the Left as a result of this decision. This is high stakes stuff for the soldiers, the nation and ultimately the presidency.
And seriously, these accusations, too little too late?! Having been on the ground in Afghanistan with US forces in 2001 and 2002 and watching the shift of focus to preparation for Iraq in mid 2002 was startling. The argument that I hear periodically from both the Left and Right, that eight years of fighting and still no progress, is simply not at all accurate. Had we not diverted our attention to Iraq (for better or worse) and truly fought on in Afghanistan, to the best of our ability, Afghanistan might truly be a different place, and we might be wrapping up now rather than getting started again.
Dodge Billingsley